Sometimes a man stands up during supper
and walks outdoors, and keeps on walking,
because of a church that stands somewhere in the East.
And his children say blessings on him as if he were dead...
And another man, who remains inside his house,
dies there, inside the dishes and the glasses
so that his children have to go far out in the world
toward that same church, which he forgot.
Poem by R.M. Rilke and translated by Robert Bly.
I am prone to crying at poetry, the same way I cry when I hear an amazing voice at a live performance; tears come in spite of myself and are unexplainable and unstoppable. Something in me has been activated and my conscious mind has nothing to do but watch in wonder and say,"oh, dear, this made me cry. This must be important." When I heard Dennis Patrick Slattery read this Rilke poem at the event at the Jung society of Austin I knew the tears were important.
As He-weasel and I heard DPS read the Rilke poem we wordlessly squeezed each other's hand in recognition. We heard in this poem the underlying theme of our exodus from our life here in the states. We both knew the inner calling that the man felt and why he had to leave his ordinary life. The man's journey to a church in the east was not one that was motivated by the desire for adventure or novelty---but rather of an inner calling that could no longer be quited or ignored.
This poem made me think of my father who longed to travel but never got farther than Honolulu or Vancouver. It made me think of all the other inner callings--big and small- he ignored. It made me think of how much booze and depression it took to quiet the callings of his heart.
Swiss Psychologist, C.G. Jung beleived “the greatest burden a child must bear is the unlived life of the parents." I wonder where I would be today if my father had dared to follow his wanderlust. I often think about the Jung quote in relation to my writing. I wonder what would I be today if my father would have dared to take his talent and wit and put it on the page instead of saving it for the occasional poem.
As long as my father was alive he was considered the writer of the family and it wasn't until death began to take him that I started to claim my role as writer. Just days before he died I got a job as an entertainment editor at a newspaper. Upon hearing my news my father said, "I am so proud of you, but I haven't the words." I have always been so struck by his use of words and the deeper implication of my father running out of them.
I know that if my father were alive to today he would be proud of me. But, I do know that he wouldn't understand why I would walk out of the house during super and walk outdoors and keep on walking until I arrived in France. He would tell me in strong tones that this church I am traveling towards is not worth it and how it is risky it is to undertake such a journey. He would ask me questions about how much money I have and whether or not I had travel insurance or whether I have good shoes and what would I do when I got there. The call is too strong in me to stop and answer his questions. I will keep walking until I arrive at that church he forgot.
Poem is available in The Rag and Bone Shop: A Poetry Anthology edited and translated by Robert Bly.
Thursday, May 22, 2008
Sometimes a man stands up during supper
Labels: France, La Belette Rouge, Poetry, Self-Indulgent, Writing


43 comments:
Another powerful entry. I think I like your dad entries the most ... then followed by the shopping ones. (You have to balance out the deep with the shallow, after all.) Good stuff, Weas. And yes, your dad would be proud of you, again and again and again.
I sent you an email on Friday but think it may be roadkill. Did you get it?
xo --
Marsi
You have labeled this post incorrectly. You should not have added "self-indulgent". Rather you should have added "truth".
This is beautiful LBR. Thank you for sharing it.
Marsi: Thank you, Marsi! I suppose as he has had such an impact on me I should not be surprised that he has snuck his way into my blog.
And, yes, it is tricky to get the balance right. I think it might be too heavy as late. Need to do some shopping posts.;-)
No, did not get email. Wonder if it is your server or mine. Please try again. And, thank you for your always gentle and kind reading.xo
Kristen: I need to find another label for this kind of post. I suppose self-indulgent isn't the best name for it. How about "subjective truth?"
F.O.T.:Thanks. I am happy you liked it.:-)
I just re-sent that email. So annoying to have them get lost!
M.
Marsi: Got it!!:-)
Great post... Thanks for that. You hit home for me in so many ways.
Justin: Thank you so much. I am really pleased you found my blog and that it happened to be on a post that resonated. Really, thanks for the comment.:-)
Beautiful.
I hear in the questions your father would ask his wish to keep you safe, and I think all parents struggle with that polarity: the wish to see one's children walk out into that world and risk, and to keep them from danger.
It's like that with my sons. My nearly 21 year old announced last night that instead of going to Majorca at the end of the summer (where a friend lives) he wants to go to India for a month. Where I have been- so I know what can happen... exaltation and pride for him extending his reach, and then little fingers of fear.
Have to balance raising these fears without hobbling his adventurousness.
la belette: i know just how you feel. i've always felt the call of other "churches"... my father, whom i adore, was a wanderer and a merchant marine at one time. he never seems to understand the places i pick to go, or why i go there, but he's been incredibly supportive. my mom, sort of sniffs at my desire to go "overseas" where they "hate americans."
my first real trip aways from my very large, extremely close family, was as a foreign exchange student in mexico the summer i turned 16. the three months there ruined me for 1 week vacations. the next time i got to go anywhere where other church bells ring was when i was studying shakespeare and classical acting at oxford. i fell madly in love with oxford, and would pack up and move there in an instant. i was encouraged to move to england and be an actor there (because they appreciate character actors much more there), but let myself be chained to the glasses and dishes and kitchen table of family relationships.
raise yourself up from your kitchen and go -- nay, fly -- to the church bells calling you.
Duchesse: Thank you.:-)
I am sure that as a parent it would be so easy to overemphasize safety and security and under emphasize adventure. Rather than fingers of fear---many parents hold their children back with both hands and arms. Your sons are so lucky to have a mother who has lived her life so fully and who supports their dreams. I am sure they know how lucky they are--and if they don't know it know, they one day will.:-)
Bonnie-Ann: Thank you so much for your comment, kind encouragement and your story. Ugh, my heart broke a little when I heard there was a church bell that you didn't get to follow. Does England and acting still ring for you? Dear, Bonnie, it is NEVER too late!!! Even if the church bell is muted by time. I hope that you too will follow your bells.xo
What a wonderfully evocative poem. You bring up one of the things I struggle with as a parent: living my own dreams vs. providing a stable environment for my children. I feel like there's a fine balance between indulging my own need for travel/stimulation/creative outlet and also being a non-flakey, not-totally-impulsive, rock solid mother. I haven't quite found it yet, but keep veering from one extreme to the other.
I Heart Fashion: First, let me reiterate and underscore, I am not a parent. So, I am probably talking outside of my realm of knowledge. But, I do know people who traveled a lot when their children were young and they have very well grounded kids. And, I know people who have never taken their kids father than the park whose children are highly fearful and anxious.
My fantasy is that you can give no better gift to your children than having a strong sense of an interior home and then giving them the world.
I don't believe that travel and stability are mutually exclusive. But, then again, I am not a mom. I am sure it is really tough to balance these two instincts. And, Jung says that we go to both extremes to find the middle. So, according to him you are doing it just right.;-)
Thank you ma belle for sharing all this with us, such powerful poem.
My father, whom I adore (RIP), toke some risks to improve our life as a family and we lived in a few cities at mainland. That marked me a lot.
Thank you so much dear for your nice words in my blog. By the way, after you've been there I made a post dedicated to you.
Very simple, but meanfull.
Go see it when you could, I'll enjoy it.
xoxo
Oh, this is so lovely, Belette. It affirms your beauty as an individual and an amazing writer!
Poetry has a profound effect upon me as well. It makes me feel so much in ways that words cannot adequately express. It makes my heart and soul swell and tears push up from behind my eyes. This poem and your experience takes that feeling even further, deeper. Thank you.
The supper that this poem features is no Last Supper for the man who stands up and walks outdoors, as you and he-weasel are doing. You can make a different choice than your father made. And you are. No doubt he would be immensely proud of you, seeing you realize something that he could not harness the courage for.
It is so absolutely rewarding and inspiring to know you. I know I say it to you almost daily but I've got my "hear me now, fear me later" pants on and I'll remind you forever just how special you are!
Seeker: I am glad you like it. Rilke is a favorite on mine. And his "Letters to a young poet" is one of my all time favorite books. I reread it every year.
Dear, Seeker,your father sounds like he was a lovely man. It is wonderful that you can see the impact of his actions on your family and how he improves things for you all.
You are so sweet. What a very lovely dedication. Yes, life does go one. I am so touched by your endless support, encouragement and friendship. Big hug to you.xoxox :-)
B: I know someone else who is standing up and walking out the door and getting in a plane and then a car---and leaving behind the safety, security and comfort of having built in book cases.
I am, as you know, immensely proud and inspired by your courage and your journey. I have all manner of pants and horses--and will bring them all out if I have to do so to remind you that you are an extraordinary writer and friend.:-)
Ma belle, I'm honoured to have you as a dear bloggy friend.
I'm glad you liked it.
No, no regrets!!!
And sweetie that's how I am, difficult to open me as a friend, but when I do it it's like for lifetime.
Luv.
xoxo
Seeker: Not sure what I did to get in that category. But, glad I did! Thanks again for the dedication and for your friendship.:-)xo
“the greatest burden a child must bear is the unlived life of the parents."
Every day I see people inflicting this on their young children.
WendyB: There is an epidemic of unlived lives. I think the entire college admission industry can be explained by this quote. Just as the parent's who are pushing their children into sports and beauty pageants. Makes me want to ask, "much unlived life?"
my mom once said to me that 'people do the best they can.' i thought this was so silly because i can think of a lot of folk that i think can do better... but when i think about my own fears and limitations, imagined or real i begin to believe that we all have stuff that holds us back. but some folk find a way to move in the direction of their dreams any way... it's not easy. i think that is why not many have the fight and courage to do so. but it seems you do...
'go confidently in the direction of your dreams. live the life you have imagined. ~henry david thoreau
you my dear, are an inspiration. bon courage!
It's a really nice post and I was happy to come back to your blog today. Thanks!
Makes me think of Robert Frost's "Two Roads diverged in a yellow wood and I took the one less traveled by and that has made all the difference."
You may be your father's daughter but you are your own person. France will welcome you and you will change. No need to feel afraid. It's exciting and you have the He-Weasel to share the journey!
L'Air du Temps:Thanks so much for your post and kind compliment!
I do think we all, no matter how hard we work to avoid it, we all have pangs of consciousness where we know where we could take a risk or grow just a bit. I am not saying that is an easy choice to make. But, ultimately I think it is harder to stay stuck in our patterns than it is to grow. It takes a lot of distraction and denial to silent the callings of our heart.
I love that Thoreau quote. Thanks for sharing it!! Yes, confidently onward...
Anne: Thanks for coming back!! And, I am so pleased you enjoyed this post.
Jacqui: Oh, that is one of my favorite poems. Deep sigh!
And, I am strangely not feeling afraid. I am keenly aware of how lucky I am not to be traveling this road alone. He-weasel is a lovely partner on this journey to our "church in the East."
Thank you, Jacqui, for your kind encouragement. :-)
Very core issues you are addressing there, girl...BRAVO!!!
I also love poetry and am a fan of Carl Jung. I think it is sweet that you and your hubby felt a connection when the poem was being read. Those are the sweet sweet strings of love being played by wings of angels passing by.
Tatting Chic: Thank you!!! But, I hate it when my core issues show.;-)
You, Tatting Chic, have the heart of a poet. Thanks so much for adding more poetry and beauty to this post with your lovely comment.
I left michigan when i was 25....headed to nyc...alone...knew nobody. My father looked at me and said "if it doesn't work out you can always come back". That stuck with me and I think of that always. Life can be boring or you can take risks....you have to follow your heart and take the risk. You loose nothing but what you have gained is so much. You can always come back or go someplace else...but at least you are going! I bet your father is looking down on you and is proud, maybe jealous...he wanted to go place, but he couldn't...you can and will.
Very moving..I don't have the right words... That took courage to post something so deep. And again, you are a wonderful writer...the reason I got hooked on your blog from the day I disovered it!
Ton amie,
SS/CC/CC
Very powerful and moving entry..I found it really inspirational personally as well. Thankyou.
Alisa: It sounds like you have always headed the call to adventure. And, what a wonderful thing to know--that home was always there for you should you need it.
So much more is lost in not following the call. Don't you think? I saw the price my father paid in ignoring it.
Thanks, Alissa, I think you are right-- he would have been proud and a little jealous. But, even if he were alive to do I still don't think he would have had the words to say so.
CC/CC/SS: Thank you. I am really and truly so appreciative of your very kind compliment. :-)
Le Tigre: I am so very pleased that you found inspiration in it. I am endlessly inspired by Rilke's writing. Merci!
You should plan life upheavals more often. Your posting is on a goddamn roll. This was wonderful. Put on those shoes and walk.
Randal: Upheaval, loss, and change are good for something. Thanks a lot, Randal. I am really happy you liked it. I have been worried that I have been a little too dark and deep as of late.
I have my Nikes on and laced.;-)
wow, Jung has a point, a good one at that and you weave it into a more powerful and poignant reflection using your own story of your Dad! I find too, our own talents and life's callings are in a sense our spirits' children...to be fostered, honored and loved...your call to follow your bliss ! well done and love the poem!thanks for sharing again and for giving me food for thought...
Dancing Doc: I am so appreciative of your gentle reading and thoughtful feedback. So happy I could provide some food for thought. Jung and Rilke are always good for a little soul food.:-)
Thanks again for coming by!
(a) It was rude of the first papa to leave during supper. Surely he could have waited until the meal was finished?
(b) I feel sorry for the man who died inside the dishes and glasses! I fear his children were ungrateful. All those wannabe stay-at-home dads should read the Rilke poem and think twice...
Seriously though... beautiful "dark and deep" post which definitely struck a chord.
i liked this post very much.
it will sit with me for a while, and i will think about it.
Gervy:
(1) I am sure he said, "Can I be excused?" before he left.
(2) Dish wear can be lethal. As anyone who does not have a dishwasher can tell you.
(3) Thank you. I am glad you liked it.
Editor:Thank you so much. It is the kind of poem that sticks with you. Isn't it? So pleased that it was meaningful for you.
You are a powerful writer. You made me yearn for France with you. And miss my dad in a sweet way. Just your words made me feel something very wonderful and disturbing, evoking my own yearnings.
Glad I popped over from French Essence to see what you are about. Well, move over, I'll be staying.
Marigail: Thank you so much for so many different things. Thanks for coming over from French Essence. Thanks for going back to some of my old posts. Merci for your tres gentile bon mots about my writing.I so appreciate your sharing what this piece brought up for you. That is a real gift for me to hear what it brought up for you.
And, finally, thanks for staying.
You needed a big sister in Alabama and I'm checking in. I am humbly grateful for your link to my site. I'll do the same.
You are a rare and vivid voice. Nice to hear your beautiful heart beat. Marigail
Post a Comment